← Back to FOI Tracker

Status: AWAITING RESPONSE  ·  One request, submitted 14 November 2026 to three bodies  ·  Responses due by 14 December 2026
Scrutiny & beds FOI NHS Devon ICB · RD&E · Torbay & South Devon NHS FT
AWAITING RESPONSE

Health scrutiny, service transfers and acute bed numbers at Torbay Hospital

Submitted: 14 November 2026 | Sent in identical terms to three bodies | Covers 1 January 2023 to the date of response, with bed figures from April 2022
Why this matters: Under regulation 23 of the Local Authority (Public Health, Health and Wellbeing Boards and Health Scrutiny) Regulations 2013, an NHS body considering a "substantial development or variation" of health services must consult the local authority's health scrutiny function. This request asks whether the Trust ever assessed the move of pathology to Gadeon House, or any other transfer of services out of Torbay Hospital since January 2023, against that threshold. It also asks for a full list of the services moved since 2023, and for monthly general and acute bed numbers alongside any plan to reduce beds or change the use of the tower block. Read together, the answers would show whether a series of changes, each treated as too small to need consultation, adds up to a substantial variation. That is the cumulative change argument the campaign has put to the Prime Minister and the Health and Social Care Committee.
Related requests: This request was sent under the same subject line as the pathology travel and equality FOI of 31 October, went to the same three bodies, and covers the consultation and capacity questions that request did not. See also the pathology decision record FOI (the Board decision and business case), TSD10513 (pathology business cases and modelling), the Board papers review FOI (ward-by-ward bed numbers and the Tower Block), Tower Block and Simpson Ward, and the campaign's letters to the Prime Minister and Health Select Committee and to Martin Wrigley MP.

Where the request stands

The campaign sent the same request on 14 November 2026 to the Trust, the RD&E and NHS Devon ICB, as it did with the 31 October request. Each body handles it under its own reference and its own clock.

Body Reference Status Response due
Torbay & South Devon NHS FT
the Trust
Reference awaited Sent 14 November 2026 14 December 2026
RD&E
Royal Devon University Healthcare NHS FT
RDF4807-26 Acknowledged 15 November 2026 14 December 2026
NHS Devon ICB
the commissioner
FOINHSD26/2016 Acknowledged 16 November 2026 14 December 2026

The RD&E date is the deadline stated in its own acknowledgement. The ICB said it would reply within 20 working days of receipt, and the Trust has not yet acknowledged the request, so both dates are the campaign's count. The request was emailed on Saturday 14 November, so it counts as received on Monday 16 November.

What the request asks for

The request is in two parts. Part A covers consultation, engagement and scrutiny. It asks for any assessment, advice or decision on whether the pathology reconfiguration or any other transfer of services since 1 January 2023 is a substantial development or variation under regulation 23, the Trust's correspondence with Torbay Council and with Devon County Council's health scrutiny function about the pathology move, records of any public consultation or engagement, any business case, options appraisal or benefits case for the move with any NHS England assurance assessment, and a list of every clinical service moved wholly or partly from Torbay Hospital since 1 January 2023 with the date and receiving site. Part B covers beds and acute capacity. It asks for the number of general and acute beds at Torbay Hospital by month from April 2022, on the same basis as the Trust's KH03 return, and any approved or proposed plan, paper or option to reduce acute bed numbers or change the use of the tower block since 1 January 2023. The full request is reproduced below.

From: Susie Colley, Director, Save Torbay Hospital Ltd, and Chair of Save Torbay Hospital
To: the Freedom of Information Officers of Torbay and South Devon NHS Foundation Trust, the Royal Devon University Healthcare NHS Foundation Trust and NHS Devon ICB, sent separately to each
Copied to: Members of Parliament and the campaign's legal advisers
Subject: FOI Act 2000 request, travel modelling, equality assessment and consultation relating to the pathology reconfiguration (Gadeon House) and other service transfers

Dear Freedom of Information Officer,

I am writing under the Freedom of Information Act 2000 to request the information set out below. Where I refer to "the pathology reconfiguration", I mean the transfer or proposed transfer of pathology services (including cellular pathology) from Torbay Hospital to Gadeon House, Exeter, in all its phases (including Phase 1 and Phase 2). Unless stated otherwise, the period covered is 1 January 2023 to the date of your response.

Part A: Consultation, engagement and scrutiny

  1. Any assessment, advice or record of decision on whether the pathology reconfiguration, or any other transfer of services from Torbay Hospital since 1 January 2023, constitutes a "substantial development or variation" of health services for the purposes of regulation 23 of the Local Authority (Public Health, Health and Wellbeing Boards and Health Scrutiny) Regulations 2013.
  2. All correspondence between the Trust (or NHS Devon ICB on the Trust's behalf) and (a) Torbay Council and (b) Devon County Council's health scrutiny function concerning the pathology reconfiguration, including any notification, briefing or referral.
  3. Records of any public consultation or patient and public engagement carried out on the pathology reconfiguration, including engagement plans, materials published and summaries of responses.
  4. Any business case (strategic outline, outline or full), options appraisal or benefits case for the pathology reconfiguration, and any NHS England assurance assessment of it.
  5. A list of all clinical services, or parts of services, that have been transferred wholly or partly from Torbay Hospital to another site since 1 January 2023, with the date of each transfer and the receiving site.

Part B: Beds and acute capacity

  1. The number of general and acute beds available at Torbay Hospital, by month, from April 2022 to the most recent month available (on the same basis as the Trust's KH03 return).
  2. Any approved or proposed plan, paper or option to reduce acute bed numbers at Torbay Hospital, or to change the use of the hospital's tower block, since 1 January 2023.

I should be most grateful to receive the answers to all the above within the 20-working-day deadline from 16 November which is 11th December 2026.

Regards

Susie Colley
Director, Save Torbay Hospital Ltd

What happens next

Three clocks are now running. Each body must respond under section 10 of the Freedom of Information Act 2000, normally within 20 working days. The request was emailed on Saturday 14 November, so it counts as received on Monday 16 November, and the 20 working days run from the following day, which sets the statutory deadline at 14 December 2026. The RD&E has given the same date in its acknowledgement. The request itself asks for a reply by 11 December 2026. Where a body holds no information for a question, it should say so. When the Trust issues a reference, or any of the three responds, this item will be updated, and any refusal notice or disclosure will be recorded here.

← Back to FOI Tracker