Five questions for Martin Wrigley MP to put to the Trust and NHS Devon
What the MP's letter says
Mr Wrigley says he meets regularly with Joe Teape, Chief Executive of the Trust, and with NHS Devon, and sits on a constituency working group looking at the transitional arrangements for NHS reform. On the estate, he describes the tower block as approximately 60 years old and says the Trust has managed fire safety risks with the fire and rescue service for many years. On pathology, he says the proposals have been brought forward partly because of the condition of the current accommodation, and that he will scrutinise them and seek assurances that patients will not be disadvantaged. On the proposed £7.5 million, which he describes as a loan, he says the decision is a matter for the Council and the Trust, and that he has raised questions about it alongside Liberal Democrat colleagues on Torbay Council. On the wider picture, he says that based on the information provided to him NHS Devon has not announced plans to downgrade Torbay Hospital, and that NHS Devon is expected to run public engagement on neighbourhood health services. His letter notes that the earlier proposal to move coronary heart care to Exeter "was not taken forward". The campaign's understanding is that the 2025 heart attack diversion plan has been paused.
What the campaign has asked
Susie Colley, Chair of Save Torbay Hospital, welcomed the MP's commitment to scrutinise the proposals and explained why the campaign keeps asking questions. She says 22 professionals working in the local health service have raised serious concerns with the campaign about planned changes across the hospital, including pathology, and that their account differs significantly from the reassurances residents are given. She says that if the facts show the concerns are unfounded, she will say so publicly. She asks Mr Wrigley to put these five questions to the Trust and NHS Devon in writing.
- What work has commenced at Gadeon House, and is it intended for the Torbay Hospital laboratory, the RD&E laboratory, or both?
- Who authorised that work and the associated expenditure, on what date, and was this a decision of the Trust Board, NHS Devon, or another body?
- If the business case is not yet complete, on what basis has work begun? Will the full business case be published, and will there be public consultation before any final decision is made?
- Which tests and services would be affected, and what turnaround times will be guaranteed for urgent, emergency and out-of-hours samples, including those supporting A&E and inpatient wards?
- What is the specific purpose of the proposed £7.5 million loan between Torbay Council and the Trust, and is any part of it connected to estate or pathology changes?
On question 5, Torbay Council's own decision record describes the £7.5 million as council borrowing to convert part of Gadeon House, which the council owns, into laboratories for the RD&E. The RD&E repays it, with interest, through a 25-year lease, and the council says the money is not a loan. The record does not say why the decision was taken under urgent powers without a vote of councillors.
The letter also asks why, if the current pathology accommodation is no longer fit for purpose, the answer is not investment in new facilities at Torbay rather than moving the work elsewhere.
From: Susie Colley, Director, Save Torbay Hospital Ltd, and Chair of Save Torbay Hospital
To: Martin Wrigley MP
Copied to: Danny Beales MP, Beccy Cooper MP, Josh Fenton-Glynn MP, Paulette Hamilton MP, Joe Robertson MP and Greg Stafford MP (members of the Health and Social Care Committee), and the campaign's legal advisers
Good evening Mr Wrigley,
I have seen the letter you recently sent to a resident (attached, who has given permission for me to publish it), about the future of Torbay Hospital, and I was pleased that your PA was able to attend the council meeting in Newton Abbot where I spoke last week. I hope she was able to pass on my points in full.
I welcome your commitment to scrutinise these proposals and to seek assurances on behalf of residents. I want to explain plainly why Save Torbay Hospital continues to ask questions.
22 professionals working within our local health service have raised serious concerns with us about the planned changes throughout the hospital which include pathology and the wider direction of travel. Their account differs significantly from the reassurances residents keep being given. I cannot simply set that aside. If they are wrong, the answer is straightforward: give us the facts. If the facts show that our concerns are unfounded, I will say so publicly and gladly apologise. Until then, I will keep asking.
The difficulty is that the responses we receive are always the same: "there are no proposals at this time" and "the business case is not yet finished". Yet your own letter refers to "proposals to relocate elements of the hospital's pathology services", and we understand that work has already begun at Gadeon House. Residents can be forgiven for finding these positions hard to reconcile.
I would therefore be very grateful if you would put the following questions to the Trust and NHS Devon in writing, and share their replies with me:
- What work has commenced at Gadeon House, and is it intended for the Torbay Hospital laboratory, the RD&E laboratory, or both?
- Who authorised that work and the associated expenditure, on what date, and was this a decision of the Trust Board, NHS Devon, or another body?
- If the business case is not yet complete, on what basis has work begun? Will the full business case be published, and will there be public consultation before any final decision is made?
- Which tests and services would be affected, and what turnaround times will be guaranteed for urgent, emergency and out-of-hours samples, including those supporting A&E and inpatient wards?
- What is the specific purpose of the proposed £7.5 million loan between Torbay Council and the Trust, and is any part of it connected to estate or pathology changes?
I would also note that your letter describes the current pathology accommodation as no longer fit for purpose. Residents would ask why the answer to that is not investment in new facilities at Torbay, rather than moving the work elsewhere.
Save Torbay Hospital is, and always has been, apolitical. We want to work with every MP and councillor across our catchment so that residents hear one clear, consistent, and accurate message. Straight answers to these five questions would go a long way towards that.
Thank you for your time. I look forward to hearing from you.
Kindest regards
Susie Colley
Director, Save Torbay Hospital Ltd
Published with the resident's permission. The resident's name and case reference have been removed.
Subject: Re: Save Torbay Hospital
Dear [resident],
Thank you for contacting me about the future of Torbay Hospital. I fully appreciate the concerns being expressed by residents about the hospital and the potential impact of proposed changes to local NHS services.
Torbay Hospital is a vital part of our local healthcare system, and I recognise how important it is to residents across Torbay and South Devon that they can continue to access safe, effective and timely hospital care close to home.
There has been considerable speculation and, in some cases, misleading information circulating about the hospital's future. I therefore want to clarify what I understand the current position to be and explain the work I am undertaking to protect local healthcare services.
My ongoing engagement with NHS leaders
I meet regularly with Joe Teape, Chief Executive of Torbay and South Devon NHS Foundation Trust, to discuss the challenges facing our local hospital, including its ageing buildings, patient safety, staffing pressures, financial sustainability and the future delivery of clinical services.
I also maintain regular dialogue with NHS Devon Integrated Care Board (ICB), which is responsible for planning and commissioning many of our local NHS services. These discussions include the Government's proposals for neighbourhood health services and the implications for hospital and community-based care.
In addition, I am involved in a constituency working group examining the transitional arrangements associated with NHS reforms. This provides a further opportunity to raise local concerns and seek accountability for decisions affecting our health services.
Torbay Hospital's ageing buildings and fire safety
One of the most significant challenges facing Torbay Hospital is the condition of its ageing estate, particularly the tower block, which is approximately 60 years old.
The Trust has been monitoring and managing fire safety risks within the building for many years and has worked closely with the fire and rescue service to maintain appropriate safety arrangements.
I continue to raise questions to the Trust about the condition of the hospital estate, the measures being taken to protect patients and staff, and the longer-term investment needed to provide modern, safe and sustainable facilities.
Proposed changes to pathology services
There has also been concern about proposals to relocate elements of the hospital's pathology services.
These proposals have been brought forward partly because of the challenges associated with maintaining services within the hospital's ageing buildings, a temporary classroom style hut which is no longer fit for purpose.
My understanding is that the proposed changes are not intended to alter how patients access pathology services. However, I recognise that residents will want reassurance about the implications for diagnostic capacity, turnaround times, clinical safety and the hospital's longer-term ability to deliver essential services.
I will continue to scrutinise these proposals and seek assurances that any changes will not disadvantage patients or undermine Torbay Hospital's clinical capabilities.
The proposed £7.5 million loan
I am also aware of concerns about the proposed £7.5 million loan involving Torbay Council and the NHS Trust.
Decisions about this financial arrangement are matters for the Council and the Trust, rather than my office. Nevertheless, I believe that any commitment of public money must be transparent, properly scrutinised and demonstrably in the interests of local residents.
Alongside Liberal Democrat colleagues on Torbay Council, I have raised questions about the proposed arrangement and the financial implications for both organisations.
Neighbourhood health reforms and the future of hospital services
NHS Devon is developing plans to implement the Government's neighbourhood health framework over the coming years.
The intention is to shift more healthcare into local communities, improve preventative services and enable patients to receive treatment closer to home wherever clinically appropriate.
In principle, better access to community-based healthcare could bring significant benefits, particularly for older people, those living with long-term conditions and patients who currently struggle to access timely support.
However, I am also conscious that these reforms are taking place against a backdrop of considerable financial pressure, workforce shortages and increasing demand for NHS services.
There are legitimate questions about whether some hospital services could be reorganised, relocated or delivered differently as these reforms progress. I believe it is essential that any changes are driven by patient need and clinical evidence, rather than simply by the need to reduce costs.
Is Torbay Hospital being downgraded?
I want to be clear that, based on the information provided to me, NHS Devon has not announced plans to downgrade Torbay Hospital.
There have previously been proposals concerning the future location of coronary heart care services, including the possibility of transferring provision to Exeter by NHS Devon. I am pleased that the particular proposal to which residents objected was not taken forward.
Nevertheless, I recognise that concerns about the future of specialist and acute services remain, and I will continue to challenge any proposals that could reduce access to essential healthcare for our communities.
Public consultation and accountability
NHS Devon is expected to undertake public engagement across Devon concerning the development of neighbourhood health services. I strongly encourage residents to participate when details are published. Local people must have a meaningful opportunity to influence how services are designed and delivered, particularly where changes could affect access to hospital treatment, urgent care or specialist services.
I will continue to press NHS leaders for transparency, clear clinical evidence and meaningful public involvement before significant decisions are made.
My commitment to residents
I remain committed to protecting Torbay Hospital's role as a major provider of acute and specialist healthcare for Torbay and South Devon.
I will continue to:
- Challenge proposals that could undermine patient safety or reduce access to essential hospital services.
- Press for investment in Torbay Hospital's ageing buildings and infrastructure.
- Scrutinise NHS financial decisions and seek assurances that patient care remains the overriding priority.
- Hold NHS Devon and the Trust accountable for the development and delivery of neighbourhood health reforms.
- Ensure that the concerns of local residents are heard by NHS leaders and Ministers.
I recognise that uncertainty about the future of our hospital causes considerable anxiety, particularly for residents who rely on its services. My priority is to ensure that Torbay Hospital remains safe, accessible and capable of meeting the healthcare needs of our growing and ageing population, both now and in the future.
Thank you again for taking the time to contact me. Please be assured that I will continue to monitor developments closely and represent the interests of our local communities.
Best regards,
Martin Wrigley MP
Member of Parliament for Newton Abbot
What happens next
There is no statutory deadline for an MP to reply. This item will be updated when Mr Wrigley responds, or when he shares replies from the Trust and NHS Devon. Questions 1 to 3 overlap with the campaign's pathology decision record FOI, to which the Trust must respond by 7 December 2026.
