← Back to FOI Tracker

Status: AWAITING RESPONSE  ·  Submitted 19 November 2026  ·  Response due by 17 December 2026
EPR Funding FOI (ref awaited) Torbay & South Devon NHS FT
AWAITING RESPONSE

How the Epic EPR is really funded, and whether it counts against the Trust's capital limit

Submitted: 19 November 2026 | Response due by 17 December 2026 | Letter to the Chief Executive: 19 November 2026
Why this matters: The Trust has given three different accounts of how its Epic electronic patient record (EPR) programme is funded. On 20 May 2026 it said EPR capital spending does not count against its capital limit (CDEL) and that the programme benefits from an exemption from capital controls. Its internal review, dated 26 June 2026, said no EPR spending falls outside the Trust's normal capital controls. Its Annual Report and Accounts 2025/26 says around £8 million of EPR investment in 2026/27 will be "met through operational capital allocations". The campaign points out that the Trust has said replacing Torbay's two cardiac catheter labs is beyond its means, and wants to know how the EPR and the cath labs were weighed against each other if both draw on the same capital.
Related requests: This request follows on from TSD10421, whose internal review offered to log the campaign's questions on CDEL treatment and the forecast under audit as a new request. See also the Devon Investment Panel FOI on the cath lab replacement.

Organisation requested to respond:

  • Torbay and South Devon NHS Foundation Trust (sent to its Freedom of Information team and the Chief Executive). Reference awaited.

What the campaign has asked

  1. National funding. The award letters, funding agreement or memorandum of understanding with NHS England for the EPR under the Frontline Digitisation Programme, with amounts, years and conditions.
  2. Funding by year and source. EPR capital spending for 2024/25, 2025/26 and 2026/27, split between national funding, system operational capital and Trust internal capital, and whether each counted against the Trust's CDEL and the Devon system capital envelope.
  3. CDEL cover. Any letter from NHS England or NHS Devon confirming CDEL cover, an uplift or other capital treatment for EPR spending.
  4. 2026/27 capital plan. The approved plan or extract showing the EPR line and the operational capital it is funded from.
  5. The 20 May answers. The records behind the Trust's earlier answers on CDEL and capital controls, and whether they are still its position.
  6. Approved budget and forecast outturn. These were withheld because they were to appear in the Accounts, but the campaign cannot find them there. The request asks for the current approved budget and the latest forecast outturn, including the forecast that was "being audited" in May.

From: Susie Colley, Director, Save Torbay Hospital Ltd
To: Freedom of Information Team, Torbay and South Devon NHS FT, and Joe Teape, Chief Executive
Copied to: Danny Beales MP, Beccy Cooper MP, Josh Fenton-Glynn MP, Paulette Hamilton MP, Joe Robertson MP and Greg Stafford MP (members of the Health and Social Care Committee), and the campaign's legal advisers
Subject: Freedom of Information Request, EPR capital funding and CDEL treatment (follow-on from TSD10421)

Dear Freedom of Information Team,

I am writing to make a new request under the Freedom of Information Act 2000. In its internal review of TSD10421, the Trust offered to log my questions on CDEL treatment and the audited forecast as a new request. I accept that offer, and I have added the questions below.

The Trust's statements on how the EPR programme is funded do not agree with each other:

  • On 20 May 2026 the Trust said EPR capital expenditure does not count against its CDEL. It also said "Yes" when asked whether the programme benefits from central spending flexibility or exemption from capital controls.
  • The internal review (dated 26 June 2026) said that no EPR expenditure falls outside the Trust's normal capital controls.
  • The Annual Report and Accounts 2025/26 (page 35) says that around £8 million of EPR investment in 2026/27 will be "met through operational capital allocations".

To clarify this, please provide the following recorded information:

  1. National funding. The award letter(s), funding agreement or memorandum of understanding between the Trust and NHS England for the EPR under the Frontline Digitisation Programme. This should include the amounts awarded, the financial years covered and any conditions attached.
  2. Funding by year and source. For 2024/25, 2025/26 and 2026/27, the EPR capital expenditure (actual or planned) split by funding source: national programme funding/PDC, ICS/system operational capital, and Trust internal capital. For each, please say whether it was scored against (a) the Trust's CDEL and (b) the Devon system capital envelope.
  3. CDEL cover. Any letter or notification from NHS England or NHS Devon ICB confirming CDEL cover, a CDEL uplift or any other capital-regime treatment for EPR expenditure. I am asking only for the confirming documents, not general correspondence.
  4. 2026/27 capital plan. The Trust's approved 2026/27 capital plan, or the relevant extract, showing the EPR line and the operational capital allocation it is funded from.
  5. Basis for the 20 May answers. The recorded information the Trust relied on when it answered "No" to Question 4(a)(i) and "Yes" to the final question on 20 May 2026. Please also confirm whether those answers are still the Trust's position, given the internal review and the 2025/26 Accounts.
  6. Approved budget and forecast outturn. These were withheld under Section 22 because they were to be published in the Accounts. I cannot find a total approved budget or forecast outturn for the programme in the 2025/26 Annual Report and Accounts. Please now provide the current total approved budget and the latest forecast outturn, including the forecast that was "being audited" when the Trust replied on 20 May.

I have limited this request to specific documents and figures so that it stays within the cost limit. If any part would exceed it, please tell me under Section 16 how to narrow it, and answer the remaining parts in the meantime.

I would prefer to receive the information electronically.

Thank you, regards

Susie Colley
Director, Save Torbay Hospital Ltd

From: Susie Colley, Director, Save Torbay Hospital Ltd
To: Joe Teape, Chief Executive, Torbay and South Devon NHS Foundation Trust
Copied to: Danny Beales MP, Beccy Cooper MP, Josh Fenton-Glynn MP, Paulette Hamilton MP, Joe Robertson MP and Greg Stafford MP (members of the Health and Social Care Committee), and the campaign's legal advisers
Subject: Contradictory Trust statements on EPR capital funding (TSD10421)

Good evening Mr Teape

I am writing to you directly because the Trust has given three different accounts of how the Epic EPR programme is funded, and they cannot all be right:

  • 20 May 2026 (FOI response): EPR capital expenditure does not count against the Trust's CDEL, and the programme benefits from an exemption from capital controls.
  • 26 June 2026 (internal review): no EPR expenditure falls outside the Trust's normal capital controls.
  • Annual Report and Accounts 2025/26 (page 35): around £8 million of EPR investment in 2026/27 will be met from operational capital allocations.

This goes beyond a technical FOI point. The Trust has said that replacing the two cardiac catheterisation labs, at £5.7 million, is beyond its means. If the EPR is now drawing on the same operational capital, the public and the Board need to know how those two priorities were weighed against each other.

I have submitted a new FOI request today asking for the documents behind each statement. I would also be grateful for your personal assurance that the Board has seen this inconsistency, and for a clear answer on which statement reflects the Trust's position.

Regards

Susie Colley
Director, Save Torbay Hospital Ltd

What happens next

Under the Freedom of Information Act the Trust must respond within 20 working days of receiving the request, which is by 17 December 2026. This item will be updated when the Trust acknowledges the request and gives it a reference, and if the Chief Executive replies to the letter.

← Back to FOI Tracker